8 minute read 2 Dec 2022

The CIO Imperative: How does technology underpin ecosystem transformation?

By Savi Thethi

EY Americas Consulting Services Technology Transformation Leader

Avid problem solver. Passionate about helping clients reinvent their business leveraging next-generation technologies. Traveler. Fishing enthusiast.

8 minute read 2 Dec 2022

Ecosystems play a critical role in accelerating transformation and maximizing value; CIOs must shape the tech strategy to drive success.

In brief
  • The current business environment is driving the rapid adoption of ecosystems – lowering risk and increasing capability.
  • These new business models present a series of technology challenges in governance, data integration, interoperability, staffing and cybersecurity.
  • Chief Information Officers (CIOs) should adopt a five-part strategy to meet these challenges and build the digital foundation of successful ecosystems.

We live in an era of increased uncertainty; customers are moving faster than corporations, and at the same time, we are surrounded by hyper-competition and rapid digitization. Companies are being forced to rethink their partnership structures and, as a result, ecosystems are emerging in almost every industry as powerful new business models.

According to recent EY Tech Horizon research, from 2020 to 2021, the share of executives who said their business is skeptical about ecosystem opportunities declined from fifty-five percent (2020) to twenty-one percent (2022). As this confidence has grown, eighty-eight percent of executives indicated they are leveraging ecosystems in their tech-enabled transformation plans, making this a vital area of interest for CIO agendas.

This edition of the CIO imperative series, which addresses critical issues and actions to help CIOs reframe the future of their organizations, sets out five actions that CIOs must embrace to cultivate a strong digital foundation to support a successful ecosystem model.

  • Ecosystem definitions

    Ecosystem business model:

    An ecosystem business model is a purposeful business arrangement between two or more entities (the members) to create and share in collective value for a common set of customers. Every ecosystem business model has participants, and at least one member acts as the orchestrator of the participants. All members in an ecosystem business model, whether orchestrators or participants, have their brands present in the value propositions.

    Industry ecosystem:

    According to analyst firm IDC, an industry ecosystem is a set of partners, customers, suppliers, service providers and competitors, within and outside an industry, that you can dynamically collaborate and innovate with as necessary to meet a given opportunity, challenge or disruption. Industry ecosystems can be organized by the different ways organizations work with their partners to leverage digital platforms, applications and technology: this could be across shared data and insights, shared applications or shared operations and expertise.

    Partner ecosystem:

    A partner ecosystem is a network of partners that a business creates and nurtures to create new market opportunities – typically via account mapping, co-selling and co-marketing.

The age of the ecosystem has arrived

According to EY research, The CEO Imperative: How mastering ecosystems transforms performance, large numbers of leading companies are doubling down on their commitment to ecosystems, eighty-seven percent report a definite trend toward (ecosystem) adoption within their industry.

Furthermore, the uncertainties of the pandemic appear to have accelerated ecosystem adoption. The average number of ecosystems operated by surveyed companies jumped from 5.5 at the beginning of the pandemic (February of 2020) to an average of 7.7 a year-and-a-half later.

Going forwards, ecosystem adoption is not going to stand still, and the same pattern is being found across industries. Eighty-six percent of executives believe that ecosystems will be a critical success factor in their industry and a further fifty-seven percent state that a lack of ecosystems in a company’s strategy will prove a serious competitive disadvantage.

high angle view of light trails in desert
(Chapter breaker)
1

Chapter 1

Why CIOs are critical to ecosystem success

CIOs must leverage technology to make their organizations the partner of choice as business ecosystem adoption accelerates.

Three broad factors bring ecosystems to the CIOs attention and will shape the technology strategies that ensure their success:

  1. An ecosystem’s ability to address and accelerate business outcomes and identify opportunities, as well as its ability to integrate different technologies.
  2. The seven distinct ecosystem business models that CIOs can use to drive growth and create value.
  3. The ecosystem’s multi-partner structure that can quickly drive innovation, value and growth, by combining the particular strengths of each partner and by sharing brand credentials to enhance the final product.

Business ecosystems address a wide range of strategic business issues and challenges. They are being used to enable growth, make operations more efficient and manage risk. According to The CEO Imperative: How mastering ecosystems transforms performance,  companies with high-performing ecosystems reported 2.1x more revenue growth and 1.5x more cost reductions than low-performing ecosystems.

CIOs and their teams have the opportunity to make their organizations the partner of choice as ecosystems grow. By adopting a platform approach, with extensive application program interfaces (APIs) and connectivity capabilities, an organization can rapidly onboard new partners while leveraging the full power of the ecosystem model.

Revenue growth through ecosystems

2.1x

more revenue growth was reported by companies with high-performing ecosystems versus companies with low-performing ecosystems.

Cost reduction through ecosystems

1.5x

more cost reductions were reported by companies with high-performing ecosystems versus companies with low-performing ecosystems.

light trails of traffic on road at night
(Chapter breaker)
2

Chapter 2

Not all ecosystems are alike

As seven distinct ecosystem models emerge, CIOs are faced with further technology challenges they must overcome.

A further variable for the CIO is that not all ecosystems are alike. We have identified seven distinct ecosystem models that companies are using. Their selection is defined by the:

  1. Level of competition
  2. Level of market dominance
  3. Commercial model

Seven ecosystem business models

Ecosystem model 

Participants

Characteristics

Examples

The symbiotic ecosystem Dominant technology company
Participants leverage the dominant company’s core platform
SAP and enterprise software providers

The marketplace ecosystem

Member place operator is the orchestrator

 

· Members pay fee to participate

· Multiple brands are present

Amazon and online vendors

The scaling ecosystem

Participants are peers, none are dominant

Participants combine strengths to achieve benefits of scale

Airlines combine to create global network

The accretive ecosystem

Non-competing firms

· Complementary products

· Common customer base

· Combine to create larger, better customer proposition

EY and P&G alliance

The co-optive ecosystem

Competitors, each with relative strengths

Leverage strengths to create improved product

Clorox and Febreze create scented trash bag

The value chain ecosystem

Different participants across a value chain

Orchestrate to achieve higher value for end customer

A digital port that combines vessel, crane, customs and warehouse operators

The integrator ecosystem

Diverse set of participants

· Integrator combines participants to create end-to-end solution

· Integrator takes full commercial responsibility for end-product

Use case of an innovative insurance platform

Each model presents a different set of technology parameters for its members’ CIOs. A primary differentiator is the dominance of the ecosystem leader. 

In symbiotic and marketplace models, dominant technology leaders act as standard setters and platforms for other participants. The CIO’s role within this model, is to create a powerful technology platform that can onboard disparate partners, while integrating data and keeping it secure.

In the more decentralized governance of the co-optive or value chain models, multiple CIOs must reach a consensus on data standards, interoperability, and cybersecurity. CIOs must recognize which system (or systems) they are operating under and the technology model it drives.

The greatest challenge for CIOs operating within an ecosystem can be the model’s participant structure. CIOs find it difficult enough to integrate data, drive common standards and maintain security within the boundaries of their enterprise. Challenges – technical, people and governance – can increase in a multi-participant environment of the business ecosystem.

Technology challenges in building business ecosystems

Technology governance

Achieving leadership and common direction is critical in any partnership or alliance. But common infrastructures, analytics and customer interface require near 100% adherence for effective operations.

Ecosystems, therefore, require a strong technology governance structure from all participants. As a practical matter, this implies a dedicated functional group to ensure internal systems are fit for purpose to interoperate in a multi-party environment, and that all governance and inter-operations are accounted for and rationalized.

Data integration

A powerful asset of successful ecosystems is the combined data of the participants. For example, a well-integrated model will create a cohesive experience for the combined customer franchises and include the offerings of each ecosystem member. Common taxonomies, integration standards, visualization and artificial intelligence (AI) will be required.

Interoperability and cloud

Ecosystem participants will each have different systems, devices, applications and communication networks. Participating CIOs will need to agree on common core standards and then build out the interfaces that enable systems to talk to each other.

The key to this dilemma will be a common cloud platform that embraces the platforms of all of the ecosystem’s members. This platform enables the ecosystem orchestrator to integrate data, set level standards for interoperability, and build a shared data fabric. The common platform will also enable a hybrid-cloud structure that meets the highest security standards of its participants. Cloud is an essential platform for the successful ecosystem.

Cybersecurity

This is an area of zero compromise. Multiple cyber-systems can present weaknesses and vulnerabilities to hackers. Breaches can then enable access to the core systems of the participants.  Here, ecosystem operators should work to adopt the strongest available zero-trust protection capabilities, not adopt the least common denominator amongst the participants.

Technology talent

In today’s business climate, all organizations are finding it a challenge to find the tech talent to staff their internal operations. The ecosystem IT team cannot be an orphan group of part-timers or second-best team members. They need to be of a skill level that matches or exceeds the standards of its participants.

car trails lights on mountain road switzerland
(Chapter breaker)
3

Chapter 3

Five steps CIOs should take to build successful ecosystems

CIOs should engage in five key actions to help realize the full benefits of ecosystem transformation.

1. Embrace, understand and plan for the ecosystem ambitions of your company

Accept that ecosystem requirements are coming your way if they have not done so already. Understand your company’s ambitions. Above all, understand which ecosystem model they are adopting and plan your technology accordingly. Also, recognize that if successful your company may adopt multiple ecosystems.

2. Construct a strong technology orchestrator function

A strong, respected and accepted central function will be required to propose trade-offs, decide common standards, and maintain strong security for all. The ecosystem IT function must be empowered to drive internal change.

3. Build to the highest common standard

Participants will inevitably come to the organization with different levels of digitization and systems. In general, you cannot ask the strongest to compromise on systems and networks that integrate with their own. Build to the highest common standard. This is particularly true in cybersecurity.

4. Leverage the data of all

Make the most of the combined data of the participants. Integrate from all sources, build common analytics and merge rich data sources into a single view of the customer and combined analytics. Combined data can be one of the greatest assets of the ecosystem.

5. Use technology to make your company the ecosystem partner of choice

Establish ecosystems as a core competence of the organization. Use a platform approach to make ecosystem partnering rapid and effective. Integrate easily and leverage the data of all participants. Make your company easy to connect and share data with, and the most capable of managing common technologies issues that may arise.

Conclusion

There are clear challenges – technological and otherwise – in making ecosystems a success. However, given the high adoption rate of ecosystems across almost every industry, avoiding these challenges is not an option for CIOs.

The larger picture is that ecosystems can create dramatic success for companies – in revenue growth, operating efficiencies and managing risk. These rewards can far outweigh the challenges of getting there. Creating excellence in ecosystem technology can be a strategic and operational driver of success in today’s complex and ever-changing business landscape.

Summary

CIOs play a pivotal role in delivering an organization’s technology strategy and in building and maintaining the tech architecture. This process involves embedding a network of business ecosystems that will help ensure successful tech-enabled transformation, delivering value, growth and a competitive edge. Recent EY research illustrates the impact ecosystems can have in accelerating business outcomes, highlighting how CIOs can lead successful ecosystem integration.

About this article

By Savi Thethi

EY Americas Consulting Services Technology Transformation Leader

Avid problem solver. Passionate about helping clients reinvent their business leveraging next-generation technologies. Traveler. Fishing enthusiast.